An HOA flag display is a common point of contention for homeowners and board members. Flags allow residents to show their patriotism and support for certain causes, but such displays can get out of hand at times. It is important for boards to understand the limitations they can impose under the law.
Is it Legal to Prohibit an HOA Flag Display in Texas?
Homeowners associations are known for restricting certain items or decorations. The goal is to preserve aesthetic appeal and, therefore, property values. Yet, flags are a whole other issue.
In Texas, an HOA can’t stop an owner from displaying the American flag, the Texas state flag, and official military flags on their private lots or homes. This is according to Section 202.012.
That said, the HOA can still set reasonable rules about how these flags are displayed. These rules are more about safety, appearance, and placement, not banning the flag itself.
But there’s an important limit to the HOA’s authority. The board must allow at least one flagpole per property, as long as it meets these conditions:
- It can be a freestanding pole in the front yard, up to 20 feet tall, or
- It can be attached to the home itself.
It is worth noting that most associations impose stricter rules for non-governmental, decorative, or political flags. For such flags, boards and owners should refer to their governing documents, particularly the CC&Rs and bylaws.
Flag Display in HOAs at the Federal Level
State laws are not the only consideration. In fact, the federal Freedom to Display the American Flag Act of 2008 prohibits HOAs from adopting rules that forbid residents from flying the U.S. flag on their own properties. That said, associations can still enforce reasonable restrictions concerning the time, place, and manner of display.
This federal law protects homeowners’ right to display the American flag, regardless of the state they live in. Still, it only applies to the U.S. flag. It does not extend to other flags, such as military flags.
Common HOA Flag Flying Rules
While state law prohibits an outright ban on specific flags, boards can still impose reasonable restrictions. Here are the typical HOA flag rules in a planned community.
1. Display Etiquette
According to both federal and Texas law, American flags must be displayed in accordance with proper display etiquette. Owners must always treat the flag with respect, never touching the ground or water. Flags must never serve as decoration or clothing. Other than that, owners can’t alter or write anything on the flag.
When flying the flag on a pole, owners must raise it quickly and lower it slowly. It must take up the highest point if other flags share the same pole. Flags must only fly from sunrise to sunset unless it receives proper illumination.
If the weather is bad, owners must take the flag inside. The exception to this is if the owner is using an all-weather flag. During periods of mourning, owners must fly the flag at half-staff.
2. Number and Materials of Flagpoles
Associations may restrict the number of flagpoles an owner can have. They may also require flagpoles to be made of durable materials. To preserve aesthetic appeal and uniformity, an HOA may also mandate that the flagpole match the home’s appearance.
3. Maintenance and Safety
In Texas, associations can reasonably regulate the display of flags for maintenance and safety purposes. For instance, flags can’t obstruct sightlines at traffic intersections. This ensures that drivers have a clear view of the road and their immediate surroundings.
Moreover, owners must always keep both the flag and the pole in good condition. Flags must not be torn, faded, or altered. Worn or damaged flags must be retired respectfully in accordance with federal law. Typically, this means burning the flag.
4. Flag Size
Associations can place limits on the size of the flag. Generally, the flag’s length should be no more than one-third to one-fourth of the height of the flagpole. This ensures suitable proportions. For residential properties, the most common flag size is 4′ x 6′ on a 20-ft pole.
5. Flag Placement
Texas law also permits associations to restrict the placement of the flagpole. Many boards limit flags to the front yard or a specific visible area. Meanwhile, other boards require placement near the home, not at the edge of the lot. Poles may also need to be positioned to avoid blocking sidewalks, driveways, or sightlines.
6. Lighting
In accordance with the U.S. Flag Code, owners must generally use proper lighting to illuminate the flag. This especially applies if the owner wishes to fly the flag at night, as displays are usually limited to between sunrise and sunset. Appropriate lighting ensures a respectful HOA flag display.
7. Noise
Believe it or not, noise complaints can also stem from flag displays. Oftentimes, the noise comes from the flagpole, and not the flag itself. A good example is when ropes clang together, disturbing neighbors. Associations can place reasonable restrictions to limit noise, especially during quiet hours.
8. Common Areas
While an HOA can’t outright prohibit owners from flying the American flag, the Texas state flag, or any U.S. Armed Forces flags on private lots, it can ban such displays in common areas. Owners have no jurisdiction over these areas, as everyone shares them. An HOA can prohibit the placement of flags or poles in the spaces it owns.
9. Local Ordinances
An association may also require owners to follow local ordinances. Typically, flagpoles must adhere to setback requirements, which are the minimum distances from property lines.
Additionally, the installation of flagpoles is often prohibited in utility easements or drainage areas. Zoning rules apply, so owners must stay vigilant to avoid penalties.
Navigating Rules on Flags
The association board generally has the authority to regulate an HOA flag display if such restrictions are set forth in the governing documents. That said, Texas law does not permit outright bans. When in doubt, board members should seek legal advice from a trained professional.
Graham Management offers exceptional HOA management services to Houston communities. Call us today at (713) 334-8000, request a proposal, or contact us online to learn more!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- Should The Board Hire A Project Manager For HOA Projects?
- Keeping Wildlife In Texas HOAs Safe: Trash, Feeding, And Community Guidelines
- Pickleball in HOAs: Noise Complaints, Court Rules, And Injury Liability