One of the core duties of an association board is HOA rule enforcement. While it may seem straightforward and simple, enforcing HOA rules can actually come with several hurdles. Many boards make mistakes, and even the smallest and most unintentional of them can trigger liability issues.

 

Can HOA Enforce Rules?

Homeowners associations and condominiums generally have the authority to adopt and enforce rules within legal limits. In Texas, HOA rule enforcement authority comes from Section 202.004. Associations also obtain this authority by their own governing documents.

That said, associations must enforce the rules in a fair and consistent manner. Homeowners can challenge discriminatory or arbitrary enforcement in court.

 

Are HOA Rules Legally Binding?are hoa rules legally binding

In general, HOA rules are legally binding, provided they were adopted properly and align with both state laws and the governing documents.

Some associations enact new rules or amend existing ones without following proper procedure, such as failing to send notice or failing to secure enough votes to pass the policy. Others have rules that directly contradict the law. For example, an HOA can’t impose a total ban on solar panels, as Texas law protects solar rights.

These are known as unenforceable HOA rules. These rules are not legally binding and are often considered void.

 

What are the Most Common HOA Rule Enforcement Mistakes?

The most common HOA enforcement mistakes include treating homeowners differently, skipping required notices, relying on memory instead of the governing documents, enforcing vague rules, enforcing rules only after complaints, failing to share updated rules, keeping poor records, and overstepping legal authority.

 

1. Treating Homeowners Differently

When board members enforce rules against some homeowners but not others, complaints are bound to arise. Associations have a legal obligation to enforce the rules equally among all residents.

 

2. Skipping Required Notices

Under Texas law, associations must provide written notice of a violation and an opportunity to be heard before imposing a penalty (Section 209.006). Skipping due process can invalidate rulings and give rise to disputes.

 

3. Relying on Memory Instead of the Governing Documents

The HOA board should never assume something is true without checking state laws and the governing documents first. Even when their intentions are pure, board members may apply the rules by mistake, leading to pushback.

 

4. Enforcing Vague Rules

Rules can be misinterpreted because of the way they are written. As much as possible, HOA boards should clarify the rules and use precedent to guide their decisions. Otherwise, owners will inevitably challenge the rules and their enforcement.

 

5. Enforcing Rules Only After Complaints

Associations should schedule routine inspections to identify potential rule violations. This demonstrates consistency. On flip side, if board members only enforce the rules after receiving complaints from residents, it can lead to claims of unfair treatment.

 

6. Failing to Share Updated Rules

Rules can change over time, and it is the board’s job to keep owners in the loop. Whenever there are changes, boards should communicate them through every channel available and in accordance with the bylaws. Even when there aren’t any changes, it is good practice to send regular reminders to raise awareness.

 

7. Keeping Poor Records

Proper recordkeeping is a big part of the board’s job, specifically the HOA secretary. It is important to maintain copies of all records, including notices, correspondence, resolutions, hearing minutes, and decisions. These can help clarify misunderstandings and even be used in the association’s defense in case of litigation.

 

8. Overstepping Legal Authority

Board members must always act within their legal authority. This means working within the boundaries of state laws and the association’s governing documents.

For example, Texas law requires associations to adopt a fine policy, as the power to impose fines is not automatic (Section 209.0061). If an HOA doesn’t have such a policy and fines owners anyway, it is working outside of its legal limits.

 

How Can an HOA Board Enforce Rules Fairly?

To avoid HOA selective enforcement, the board must follow the association’s enforcement policy, verify violations before acting, communicate often and proactively, and keep personal conflicts separate.

 

1. Follow the HOA Enforcement Policy

Every association should have established guidelines for HOA rule enforcement. Under Texas law, this includes providing written notice and an opportunity to be heard before imposing penalties. Fines also require a formal fine policy.

Additionally, the enforcement process should outline the proper escalation schedule. Unless there’s an immediate threat to safety, which would require quick action, the board shouldn’t skip any steps.

Associations must apply this policy to each and every violation. No one should get a pass just because of who they are or who they know. Even board members are not exempt.

 

2. Verify Violations Before Acting

Boards should investigate each violation before pursuing enforcement action. This involves checking state laws and the governing documents to verify that a violation has, indeed, taken place. Associations must adopt an objective eye when reviewing violations or complaints.

 

3. Communicate Often and Proactively

Open communication is a must for all communities. This means giving advance notice when required, including before enforcement, when clarifying rules, and restarting enforcement on past rules that were overlooked.

 

4. Keep Personal Conflicts Separate

When it comes to HOA rule enforcement, there is no room for personal bias, favoritism, or judgment. Board members should always look at violations through an objective lens. If it becomes too personal, recusal can help avoid conflicts of interest.

Some associations find it difficult to enforce the rules or pursue delinquent dues against their own neighbors and friends. A good solution is to hire an HOA management company to assume this role instead. This can help eliminate any potential awkwardness.

 

What Happens When HOA Rules are Not Enforced?hoa enforcement

When an association fails to enforce the rules, it can lose the right to HOA rule enforcement in the future and even face legal problems. Common consequences include:

  • Loss of Enforcement Rights. When an HOA goes on for too long without enforcing the rules, it can render the rules void or weaken the board’s authority.
  • Selective Enforcement Claims. Homeowners may challenge the association for enforcing the rules unequally or arbitrarily. This can lead to lawsuits.
  • Diminished Trust. Residents may stop paying their dues or complying with the rules because they feel the board isn’t doing its job properly. Some may even be openly hostile.
  • Lower Property Values. Rules exist to maintain order and appearance within a community. When the board stops enforcing the rules, architectural changes can go unchecked, nuisance behavior can run rampant, and maintenance obligations can be ignored. Property values can plummet as a result.

 

Can You Sue an HOA for Not Enforcing Rules?

In general, homeowners can sue an HOA for failing to enforce the rules, but lawsuits can be time-consuming and expensive. Most experts agree that it should come as a last resort.

When HOA rule enforcement falls by the wayside, most owners react instinctively by initiating legal action. Yet, lawsuits can take a lot of time and exhaust resources. An HOA may even have to raise dues or levy special assessments to cover the resulting legal fees. Plus, there’s no guarantee of winning.

Instead of a lawsuit, owners should find alternative solutions. Talking to the HOA board or raising the concern at a meeting are good first steps. If those don’t work, internal dispute resolution or ADR are viable options. Finally, removing problem board members and replacing them with more competent ones can help fix the issue.

 

Avoiding Conflict and Errors

Proper HOA rule enforcement is essential to maintaining order and harmony within a community. Board members must be careful not to let personal biases influence their decisions and should always refer to state laws and their governing documents. While mistakes can happen, establishing and following a clear enforcement policy can go a long way in preventing disputes.

Take the stress out of running your Texas HOA with help from Graham Management. Our HOA management services give boards the support they need to keep their communities running smoothly. Call us today at (713) 334-8000, request a proposal, or contact us online to begin!

 

RELATED ARTICLES: